St. Augustine Civil Litigation Attorney | Business & Contract Lawsuits in Florida

When legal disputes arise—whether over a contract, property, construction, or injury—you need a litigation team that understands the law, has court experience, and will go to trial. At St. Johns Law Group, our team of over 10 experienced attorneys and mediators provides comprehensive representation in civil litigation matters across Florida.

Whether you’re involved in a small claims action or a complex lawsuit in Circuit Court, we protect your rights at every stage—from demand letters and initial filings to trial and appeal.

Complete Civil Litigation Representation

We handle a broad range of civil disputes, including:

• Breach of Contract

• Real Estate & Property Disputes

• Construction Litigation

• Contested Estates & Probate Challenges

• Insurance Disputes & Denials

• Personal Injury & Auto Accidents

We analyze your case early, build a tailored litigation strategy, and aggressively represent your interests both in and out of court.

Proven Trial Experience

Our attorneys bring deep courtroom experience to every case:

• Over 65 jury trials

• Hundreds of non-jury trials

• Decades of combined litigation experience in county, circuit, and appellate courts

Several of our litigators have been trying cases in St. Augustine for more than 20 years.

Representative Litigation Attorneys:

• Douglas Burnett – Complex Lawsuits
• James Hatfield – Tax & Revenue Disputes
• Rachael Greene – Divorce & Family Law
• Hillary Mesa – HOA & Condo Association
• Alex Nunchuck – Personal Injury & Insurance Disputes
• Shaun Saliba – Construction & Property Litigation
• Felecia Walker – Probate, Trusts & Bankruptcy
• James Whitehouse – Land Development & Zoning Appeals

Key Civil Litigation Services

Strategic Litigation Planning

We begin every case by identifying the strengths, weaknesses, and legal options—setting the stage for favorable outcomes, whether through settlement or trial.

Discovery & Evidence Management

Our attorneys are experienced in the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, issuing subpoenas, handling depositions, and defending against overbroad discovery demands, all while protecting confidential information.

Motions & Legal Briefs

We draft persuasive motions to dismiss, motions for summary judgment, and legal memoranda supported by strong case law—designed to persuade judges and enhance opportunities to win.

Trial Preparation & Appeals

We prepare every case with trial in mind. If necessary, our appellate team is ready to continue your fight in the Florida District Courts of Appeal.

Common Civil Disputes We Handle

• Breach of Contract & Commercial Agreements

• Real Estate & Title Disputes

• Boundary, Easement & Survey Issues

• Deposit Disputes & Interpleaders

• HOA & Condo Covenant Enforcement

• Construction Defects & Delay Claims

• Lien Foreclosure & Contractor Disputes

• Landlord-Tenant Disputes & Evictions

• Personal Injury & Vehicle Accident Claims

• Insurance Coverage & Bad Faith Claims

• Injunctions & Declaratory Relief

• Enforcement of Judgments

• Arbitration, Mediation, Trials & Appeals

Served with a Lawsuit? Time is Critical.

If you’ve been served with a Complaint, Petition, or Summons, you generally have 20 days to respond in Florida. Don’t wait—our litigation attorneys will:

• Analyze the allegations and evidence

• Identify legal defenses or counterclaims

• Develop a litigation strategy

• Handle court filings and representation

We offer consultations in person, by phone, or via Zoom/Teams to fit your needs.

Need to File a Lawsuit or Send a Demand Letter?

Our attorneys regularly initiate legal action, including:

• Pre-suit mediation demands (especially for HOA disputes)

• Construction defect notices

• Insurance pre-suit notices

• Demands for payment or contract performance

Timing matters—statutes of limitations, contract deadlines, and notice requirements can impact your ability to recover.

Insurance Disputes & Defense

If you’re sued or suffer a loss, your insurance policy may entitle you to coverage or legal defense. If your insurer denies coverage or fails to defend you, we can:

• Review policy terms and exclusions

• Advise you on your rights and obligations

• Monitor or challenge your insurer’s legal representation

• File a bad faith claim or lawsuit, if necessary

Attorney Alex Nunchuck, a former insurance defense lawyer, brings strategic insight into navigating and resolving insurance disputes.

Appeals & Post-Trial Advocacy

We don’t stop at trial. Our attorneys are skilled in preserving appellate issues, writing briefs, and arguing before appellate courts. If you need to appeal—or defend against one—we’re ready.

Areas We Serve

St. Johns Law Group represents litigation clients throughout Northeast Florida and Southern Georgia, including:

St. Johns County – St. Augustine, St. Augustine Beach, Ponte Vedra, Nocatee, Vilano Beach, Julington Creek, Fruit Cove, World Golf Village, Palm Valley, Hastings, Elkton, Silverleaf, Beachwalk.

Flagler County – Palm Coast, Flagler Beach, Bunnell, Marineland.

Duval County – Jacksonville, Jacksonville Beach, Atlantic Beach, Neptune Beach, San Marco, Mandarin, Southside.

Clay County – Green Cove Springs, Fleming Island, Middleburg, Keystone Heights, Oakleaf Plantation.

Putnam County – Palatka, East Palatka, Interlachen, Crescent City, Welaka.

Southern Georgia (select matters) – St. Marys, Kingsland, Woodbine.

We handle both plaintiff and defense cases and often work with clients to resolve disputes through negotiation or mediation before trial becomes necessary.

📞 Let Our Litigation Team Fight for You

Whether you’re suing or being sued, or just seeking legal advice before acting—St. Johns Law Group is here to guide you with experience, strategy, and strength in the courtroom.

Contact us today to schedule your consultation.  Call (904) 495-0400 or complete our online contact form.

We’re ready to help—in person, online, or over the phone.