Property Claims • Coverage Disputes • Litigation

Property Damage LawyerSt. Augustine, Florida

Help with denied coverage, underpaid claims and damage to homes, businesses and community property. St. Johns Law Group represents property owners in St. Augustine and throughout Northeast Florida.

St. Johns Law Group
St. Augustine Area’s Largest Law Firm
15 Attorneys
Full-Service Legal Team
300+ Years
Combined Legal Experience
100+ Jury Trials
Trial Experience Across the Team
1,000s of Closings
Real Estate Transactions
One Legal Team

Your Property. Your Policy. Your Legal Options.

Serious property damage can create several disputes at once: what caused the loss, what repairs are needed, what the policy covers and who should pay. Our attorneys bring together civil litigation, construction, real estate and community association experience to evaluate those issues.

As St. Augustine Area’s Largest Law Firm, St. Johns Law Group serves homeowners, business owners, landlords, investors, condominium associations and homeowners’ associations throughout Northeast Florida.

St. Johns Law Group attorneys outside the firm’s St. Augustine office
Based in St. Augustine. Serving property owners throughout Northeast Florida.
Alex Nunchuck, attorney at St. Johns Law Group

Alex Nunchuck

Insurance coverage disputes
Property damage & civil litigation

View Attorney Profile →
Insurance Coverage & Property Damage Litigation

Experience Suing Insurance Companies Over Coverage Denials

Alex Nunchuck represents property owners in lawsuits against insurance companies over denied coverage. His prior insurance-defense and first-party property-insurance experience provides additional perspective when evaluating an insurer’s position, the policy language and litigation strategy.

His practice includes insurance claims and denials, property damage disputes, contract litigation and appeals. He helps clients assess the evidence, understand their options and pursue the remedies available under the policy and Florida law.

Representative Result • 2026

$500,000+Home Fire Damage Recovery

Alex Nunchuck’s experience includes a $500,000+ recovery for a client following home fire damage in 2026.

Every case is different. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Claims We Handle

Property Damage Claims & Related Disputes

We review the cause of the damage, the available insurance and the potential responsibility of other parties. Coverage and recovery depend on the policy, the facts and the applicable law.

Sinkholes, settlement and collapse: Soil movement and structural failure can raise distinct engineering and coverage questions. We evaluate the policy and evidence without assuming that all ground movement or repair costs are covered.

When the Insurer Says No

A Coverage Denial Deserves a Careful Review

A denial letter is the insurer’s position on your claim. We compare that position with the policy, the loss evidence and the law to determine whether it can be challenged.

Our work may include requesting a clear coverage explanation, developing additional evidence, addressing disputed estimates and pursuing negotiation, mediation or a lawsuit when appropriate.

Alex Nunchuck’s experience litigating coverage denials supports a practical assessment of both the insurer’s arguments and the property owner’s available remedies.

Questions We Examine

  • What policy language or exclusion does the insurer rely on?
  • What caused the damage, and what evidence supports that cause?
  • Does the estimate address the full scope of necessary repairs?
  • Have notice, inspection and proof-of-loss requirements been met?
  • Is appraisal, mediation or litigation appropriate for this dispute?

A denied or underpaid claim does not automatically establish bad faith. Any additional claim requires its own legal and procedural analysis.

The Cause of Loss Matters

Different Damage Can Raise Different Coverage Questions

The condition of the property, the cause of the loss and the policy wording all matter. We help organize those issues before selecting a course of action.

Fire & Smoke Damage

A fire claim may involve structural repairs, smoke and soot remediation, damaged contents and additional living expenses. We examine the scope of the loss and the relevant coverage, limits, deductibles and documentation.

Preserve fire reports, photographs, inventories, estimates and receipts for temporary housing or emergency work.

Storm & Roof Damage

Wind, rain, debris, age and prior conditions can become competing explanations for roof or structural damage. The evidence should distinguish the claimed loss from unrelated wear or preexisting conditions.

Inspection findings, maintenance records, weather information and repair estimates can help clarify the dispute.

Water Intrusion & Flooding

A plumbing leak, wind-driven rain and rising floodwater can receive different treatment under a policy. Homeowners insurance generally excludes flood damage, and mold coverage may be limited or excluded.

Separate flood insurance, including an NFIP policy, requires its own review. Florida DFS homeowners insurance overview ↗

How We Help

A Clear Approach to Your Property Damage Dispute

We develop the claim around the policy, the evidence and the available legal remedies, while keeping you informed about the decisions ahead.

  1. Review the Policy & Claim

    Identify the coverage issues, the insurer’s stated position, relevant dates and any immediate notice or litigation requirements.

  2. Develop the Evidence

    Organize photographs, estimates, correspondence and reports. Where appropriate, work with contractors, adjusters, engineers or other specialists.

  3. Evaluate Resolution Options

    Consider additional submissions, negotiation, appraisal or mediation in light of the policy and the nature of the disagreement.

  4. Litigate When Appropriate

    When the facts and law support suit, prepare the claim, address applicable pre-suit requirements and pursue the case in court.

Report the Loss Promptly

Protect the Evidence. Review the Deadlines.

Claim reporting, proof of loss, pre-suit procedures and the deadline to file a lawsuit are separate requirements. The right dates depend on the policy, the loss, the type of claim and the applicable law.

Take reasonable steps to prevent further damage when safe, document the condition and keep repair and mitigation receipts. Coordinate inspections and preserve relevant evidence before disposal or permanent repair when practicable.

Do not assume that ongoing discussions with the insurer extend a deadline. Flood policies and construction-defect claims can follow different procedures.

Helpful Records for Your Consultation

  • The policy, declarations page and endorsements
  • The date of loss and a timeline of claim communications
  • Denial, reservation-of-rights and payment letters
  • Photographs, videos and an inventory of damaged items
  • Repair estimates, inspection reports and expert findings
  • Emergency repair, mitigation and temporary housing receipts
  • Construction contracts, warranties or association records, if relevant

An initial inquiry to the firm does not report a loss to the insurer, satisfy policy duties or extend a deadline.

Common Questions

Property Damage & Insurance Claim FAQs

These answers provide general information. Your policy, facts and claim dates need individual review.

Can you sue an insurance company after a coverage denial?

A lawsuit may be appropriate if the insurer has breached its obligations and the necessary policy and pre-suit requirements have been met. We first examine the denial, the policy and the supporting evidence. Additional documentation, negotiation or mediation may also be useful depending on the dispute.

How long do I have to report property damage in Florida?

Report the loss promptly and follow the policy’s requirements. Under current Florida law, an initial or reopened property insurance claim generally must be reported within one year after the date of loss, and a supplemental claim generally within 18 months. Exceptions, policy dates and earlier versions of the law can affect the analysis. These notice periods are separate from the deadline to file a lawsuit.

Read Florida Statutes § 627.70132 ↗

Does homeowners insurance cover all hurricane or water damage?

No. Wind damage, rain intrusion, plumbing leaks and rising floodwater can raise different coverage questions. Homeowners insurance generally excludes flooding. The policy’s exclusions, endorsements, limits and deductibles, together with evidence of the cause of loss, must be reviewed.

Are NFIP flood insurance claims subject to different rules?

Yes. National Flood Insurance Program claims follow separate federal rules, including proof-of-loss, administrative-appeal and lawsuit deadlines. An appeal to FEMA does not extend the time to sue. Have the flood policy and any denial letter reviewed promptly. Private flood policies require their own analysis.

NFIP guidance on denied flood claims ↗

What if poor construction caused the damage?

The matter may involve a claim against a contractor, subcontractor or design professional, an insurance coverage issue, or both. We evaluate those paths separately. Florida’s Chapter 558 notice procedures may apply, and construction claims have their own limitation and repose rules.

Read the construction-defect notice statute ↗

Can appraisal resolve a dispute with my insurer?

An appraisal provision may help resolve a disagreement about the amount of a covered loss. Whether appraisal is available, what it can decide and how it affects other options depend on the policy and the dispute. Coverage questions and compliance with policy conditions may need separate legal analysis.

Does a denial or low payment automatically amount to bad faith?

No. A disagreement over coverage or valuation does not automatically establish bad faith. Florida law imposes specific substantive and procedural requirements for additional remedies against a property insurer. We assess the conduct and procedural history before recommending such a claim.

Read Florida Statutes § 624.1551 ↗

Will the insurance company pay my attorney’s fees?

Recovery of attorney’s fees from an insurer is not automatic. It depends on the applicable law, the policy and claim dates, and the issues involved. The firm explains the proposed fee arrangement and costs before an engagement agreement is accepted.

Areas We Serve

St. Augustine & Northeast Florida Property Owners

Our office is at 104 Sea Grove Main Street in St. Augustine. We represent clients in residential and commercial property damage disputes throughout the First Coast, including coastal, Intracoastal and inland communities.

St. Johns County

St. Augustine • St. Augustine Beach • Vilano Beach • Ponte Vedra Beach • Nocatee • Hastings • Switzerland • Fruit Cove • Julington Creek • Palm Valley

Duval County

Jacksonville • Jacksonville Beach • Atlantic Beach • Neptune Beach • Baymeadows • Mandarin • San Marco • Southside

Flagler County

Palm Coast • Bunnell • Flagler Beach • Beverly Beach

Clay County

Fleming Island • Green Cove Springs • Orange Park • Middleburg • Keystone Heights

Putnam County

Palatka • East Palatka • Crescent City • Interlachen • Pomona Park

Speak With Our Property Damage Team

Discuss the Damage, the Denial & Your Next Step

Whether you are preparing a claim, disputing an underpayment or challenging a coverage denial, contact St. Johns Law Group for a free consultation about your property damage matter.

St. Johns Law Group, P.A.
104 Sea Grove Main Street
St. Augustine, Florida 32080

View St. Johns Law Group on Google Maps ↗

An initial inquiry does not extend an insurance or court deadline. Representation requires a conflict review and a written engagement agreement accepted by the firm.

Request a Free Consultation

Briefly identify the property damage, the status of the insurance claim and any known deadline. Please do not include confidential or sensitive details in this initial inquiry.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship or confirm that the firm will handle your claim.