St. Augustine Area's Largest Law Firm
Florida Construction Defect Claims & Disputes
Construction defects can affect the safety, value, and long-term usability of residential and commercial properties. Florida law provides specific rules governing how construction defect claims must be identified, disclosed, and resolved. Understanding these rules is essential for property owners, developers, contractors, and builders facing defect-related disputes.
What Is a Construction Defect Under Florida Law?
A construction defect generally refers to a flaw in design, workmanship, materials, or construction that results in damage or failure of a structure. Defects may be immediately visible or may remain hidden for years before becoming apparent.
Common categories of construction defects include:
- Design defects caused by architectural or engineering errors
- Workmanship defects resulting from improper installation or construction methods
- Material defects involving substandard or inappropriate building materials
- Code violations that fail to meet Florida building standards
Residential vs. Commercial Construction Defect Claims
Construction defect disputes arise in both residential and commercial projects, but the issues involved often differ. Residential defect claims frequently involve water intrusion, roofing failures, foundation movement, and structural deficiencies. Commercial defect claims may include complex design failures, system-wide defects, or large-scale compliance issues.
The size and scope of the project often influence how defects are evaluated, documented, and resolved under Florida law.
Pre-Suit Notice and Florida’s Construction Defect Process
Florida law requires property owners to follow specific pre-suit procedures before filing a construction defect lawsuit. These procedures are intended to encourage early resolution and provide builders and contractors with an opportunity to inspect and repair alleged defects.
The pre-suit process typically involves:
- Providing written notice of the alleged defects
- Allowing inspection of the property
- Receiving proposed repairs or settlement offers
Failure to comply with these requirements may delay or limit a defect claim.
Disclosure Obligations and Latent Defects
Construction defect claims often intersect with disclosure obligations during property sales. Florida courts require sellers to disclose known latent defects that materially affect the value of residential property. When construction defects are concealed or not disclosed, disputes may arise long after a sale has closed.
These disclosure issues are frequently tied to claims involving water intrusion, structural damage, or other defects that are not readily observable during a standard inspection.
Construction Defects and Contractual Risk Allocation
Construction contracts play a critical role in defect disputes. Contract provisions addressing warranties, indemnification, limitations of liability, and dispute resolution often determine how defect claims are handled and who bears responsibility.
Poorly drafted or ambiguous contracts can significantly increase the risk of prolonged litigation when defects arise.
Litigation vs. Resolution of Construction Defect Disputes
Not all construction defect claims lead to litigation. Many disputes are resolved through negotiated repairs, settlements, mediation, or arbitration. In other cases, formal litigation may be necessary to resolve complex liability issues or significant damages.
Each defect claim presents unique legal and factual considerations that influence how disputes progress.
Understanding Your Legal Options
Construction defect disputes can involve multiple parties, overlapping legal duties, and strict procedural requirements. Early legal guidance can help clarify rights, obligations, and potential exposure under Florida law.
For broader guidance on construction-related legal issues, visit our Construction Law practice page.
Questions about a potential construction defect dispute?
Contact Us:
- 104 Sea Grove Main Street | St. Augustine, Florida 32080
