Commercial disputes can threaten valuable contracts, real estate investments, development projects, revenue streams, professional relationships, and the long-term stability of an enterprise. When negotiations break down or litigation becomes unavoidable, businesses and property owners need counsel capable of analyzing the transaction, developing a practical strategy, and presenting the case effectively in court.
St. Johns Law Group represents businesses, investors, developers, property owners, professionals, lenders, landlords, tenants, contractors, and other commercial clients in complex disputes throughout St. Augustine, St. Johns County, Northeast Florida, and selected matters across Florida.
We are Trial Attorneys – 3 Jury Trials, 3 Months, 3 Wins – CLICK HERE
14 Attorneys with 300+ Years of Combined Experience
Our commercial litigators handle cases involving contracts, commercial real estate, construction, development, leasing, financing, professional services, fraud, restrictive covenants, and other business-to-business disputes. We represent clients at every stage of a controversy—from early risk assessment and demand letters through mediation, arbitration, trial, and appeal.
Pro Tip: Before hiring a litigation attorney, ask how many cases they have taken to trial and if they have a successful trial team.
Commercial litigation is the process of resolving disputes arising from commercial transactions and business relationships. These cases often involve contracts, substantial financial interests, multiple parties, technical evidence, or complicated factual and legal issues.
Unlike a routine collection matter, a commercial lawsuit may affect:
Ownership or control of valuable property
The enforceability of an important contract
The completion of a construction or development project
Continued access to leased premises
A company’s revenue or cash flow
A professional or business reputation
The ability to compete in a particular market
Long-term relationships with customers, vendors, lenders, or investors
Effective representation requires more than filing pleadings. A commercial litigator must understand the underlying transaction, identify leverage, preserve evidence, evaluate financial exposure, and build a strategy aligned with the client’s broader objectives.
Contracts form the foundation of most commercial relationships. When one party fails to perform, delays performance, refuses payment, improperly terminates an agreement, or violates another material term, the resulting breach can cause substantial losses.
Our litigators represent plaintiffs and defendants in disputes involving:
Purchase and sale agreements
Service agreements
Consulting agreements
Vendor and supplier contracts
Distribution agreements
Development agreements
Commercial leases
Construction agreements
Professional-services contracts
Financing agreements
Settlement agreements
Confidentiality and nondisclosure agreements
Noncompetition and nonsolicitation provisions
Letters of intent and preliminary agreements
Potential remedies may include monetary damages, declaratory relief, specific performance, injunctive relief, rescission, restitution, or recovery of attorney’s fees when authorized by contract or law.
Commercial real estate disputes frequently involve high-value property, complex agreements, financing arrangements, governmental approvals, and time-sensitive development plans.
Our attorneys handle commercial real estate disputes involving:
Purchase and sale contracts
Failed commercial closings
Specific-performance claims
Broker and commission disputes
Lender and borrower controversies
Our firm’s experience in real estate transactions, development, land use, construction, and litigation allows us to evaluate both the legal dispute and the underlying property issues.
Commercial landlords and tenants may face disputes involving rent, operating expenses, repairs, maintenance, insurance, common-area charges, exclusivity provisions, assignment rights, renewal options, defaults, and possession of the premises.
We represent commercial landlords and tenants in matters involving:
Unpaid rent and additional rent
Lease defaults
Commercial eviction
Common-area maintenance charges
Repair and maintenance obligations
Tenant improvements
Assignment and subletting
Personal guaranties
Use restrictions
Exclusivity provisions
Renewal and purchase options
Surrender and restoration obligations
Early termination
Damage to leased property
Because the language of the lease often controls the outcome, we carefully analyze the entire agreement, amendments, guaranties, notices, payment history, and communications between the parties.
Construction disputes can delay projects, increase costs, impair financing, and create competing claims among owners, developers, contractors, subcontractors, design professionals, and suppliers.
St. Johns Law Group handles commercial construction and development disputes involving:
Construction delays
Change orders
Scope-of-work disputes
Construction liens
Payment bonds
Contractor licensing
Design and engineering issues
Project abandonment
Indemnification and insurance obligations
Developer and contractor disputes
We work to understand the contract documents, plans, schedules, payment applications, change orders, inspection records, expert reports, and project communications necessary to present or defend the claim.
Commercial disputes may involve allegations that a party made false statements, concealed important facts, misrepresented financial information, or induced another party to enter a transaction through deception.
Claims may involve:
Fraudulent inducement
Negligent misrepresentation
Concealment of material facts
False financial statements
Misrepresentations concerning property or assets
Deceptive sales practices
Improper transfers of assets
Constructive fraud
Rescission of a transaction
Fraud claims are fact-intensive and generally require careful examination of what was represented, what was omitted, when the statements were made, and whether the other party reasonably relied on them.
We represent businesses in contested commercial collection matters, including cases involving:
Unpaid invoices
Promissory notes
Personal guaranties
Account stated claims
Commercial loan defaults
Fraudulent transfers
Judgment enforcement
Garnishment
Proceedings supplementary
Asset discovery
Challenges to collection efforts
Our objective is not merely to obtain a judgment. When representing a creditor, we evaluate whether assets exist, whether security interests or guaranties are enforceable, and whether collection is realistically achievable.
Restrictive-covenant disputes can arise when an employee, owner, contractor, or professional leaves a company and begins competing, soliciting customers, recruiting employees, or using confidential information.
We represent parties in disputes involving:
Noncompetition agreements
Nonsolicitation agreements
Confidentiality provisions
Trade secrets
Customer lists
Proprietary business information
Employee departures
Requests for temporary injunctions
Geographic and time restrictions
Because these cases often require immediate action, it is important to evaluate enforceability, available evidence, potential business harm, and the standards for emergency injunctive relief as early as possible.
Our commercial litigation practice also includes disputes involving physicians, dentists, medical practices, professional associations, healthcare businesses, and other professional organizations.
These cases may involve:
Employment agreements
Compensation disputes
Practice acquisitions
Professional departures
Restrictive covenants
Management-service agreements
Commercial leases
Ownership disagreements
Vendor and service contracts
Billing and collection disputes
Buyout provisions
Professional-service agreements
Our broader healthcare business, commercial real estate, transactional, and litigation experience allows us to address the interconnected issues that frequently arise in professional-practice disputes.
St. Johns Law Group represents both plaintiffs bringing commercial claims and defendants responding to lawsuits.
2026 Jury Trial Win for Defendant – Avoiding 8-Figure Judgement in Commercial Litigation
2026 Jury Trial Win for Plaintiff – $55,650 in Construction Claim if Lien Recovered Plus Attorneys’ Fees and Costs
2026 Jury Trial Win for Defendant/Counter-Plaintiff in $280,000 Real Estate Contract Dispute Plus Attorneys’ Fees and Costs
Representing both sides provides valuable perspective. A plaintiff must establish each legal element, prove damages, overcome defenses, and determine whether a favorable judgment can be collected. A defendant must identify procedural, factual, and legal weaknesses in the claim while managing litigation risk and protecting business operations.
Our attorneys evaluate:
The governing contracts
Potential causes of action
Available defenses and counterclaims
Documentary and electronic evidence
Witness credibility
Recoverable damages
Insurance coverage
Attorney’s-fee provisions
Injunctive-relief issues
Collection and enforcement concerns
The cost and business disruption associated with litigation
Some commercial disputes cannot wait for a final judgment. Immediate relief may be necessary to prevent the transfer of property, misuse of confidential information, violation of a restrictive covenant, destruction of evidence, interference with access, or other irreparable harm.
2025 Emergency Injunction against partnership theft
2024 Emergency Injunction against theft of confidential business information and breach of noncompete
Our litigators handle requests for and defenses against:
Temporary restraining orders
Temporary injunctions
Permanent injunctions
Lis pendens
Receiverships
Preservation of evidence
Expedited discovery
Declaratory relief
Emergency litigation requires rapid factual investigation, careful preparation of supporting evidence, and a realistic assessment of whether the legal requirements for extraordinary relief can be established.
Not every commercial dispute should be tried. A negotiated resolution may reduce cost, preserve confidentiality, protect relationships, and provide business terms that a court could not order.
Our attorneys represent clients in:
Pre-suit negotiations
Court-ordered mediation
Voluntary mediation
Contractual arbitration
Settlement conferences
Structured buyouts
Payment arrangements
Business separations
Property transfers
Confidential settlements
We prepare for mediation with the same attention given to litigation. A strong settlement position often depends on demonstrating that the client is prepared to proceed through trial when necessary.
Some commercial disputes cannot be resolved through negotiation. When trial becomes necessary, the case must be developed around admissible evidence, credible witnesses, understandable themes, and the governing law.
65+ Jury Trials – Experience You Need
Our trial preparation may include:
Fact and document investigation
Preservation of electronic evidence
Depositions
Written discovery
Expert-witness coordination
Dispositive motions
Motions in limine
Trial exhibits and demonstratives
Witness preparation
Jury selection
Opening statements
Direct and cross-examination
Closing arguments
Post-trial motions
St. Johns Law Group uses a team-oriented approach in substantial litigation matters, drawing upon attorneys with experience in commercial law, real estate, construction, land use, appeals, and related fields.
Commercial litigation may continue after the trial court enters an order or judgment. Our attorneys handle appellate and post-judgment matters involving:
Final judgments
Nonfinal appealable orders
Injunctions
Summary judgments
Preservation of appellate issues
Post-trial motions
Judgment enforcement
Proceedings supplementary
Garnishment
Discovery in aid of execution
Early coordination with appellate counsel can help preserve issues and create a more effective record before the case reaches the appellate stage.
Our litigation team is supported by attorneys experienced in commercial transactions, real estate, land development, construction, leasing, healthcare business law, and business structuring. That broader perspective helps us understand how the dispute arose and what resolution makes commercial sense.
We prepare cases with trial in mind while remaining alert to practical opportunities for settlement. A credible ability to proceed to trial can significantly affect negotiations.
Litigation decisions should account for more than theoretical legal rights. We consider expense, timing, reputation, operational disruption, collectability, and the client’s long-term objectives.
Our firm is based in St. Augustine and regularly represents clients throughout St. Johns County and Northeast Florida. We combine local experience with the resources of a multidisciplinary litigation and transactional team.
Commercial disputes often require prompt decisions. We work to keep clients informed, explain available options, and develop strategies appropriate to the stakes of the case.
You should consult an attorney when a material breach, payment dispute, threatened lawsuit, failed closing, lease default, construction problem, or other significant controversy develops. Early legal advice may help preserve evidence, satisfy notice requirements, avoid damaging communications, and improve settlement options.
Yes. Many disputes are resolved through demand letters, direct negotiations, mediation, or contractual dispute-resolution procedures. The appropriate approach depends on the urgency of the matter, the parties’ positions, and whether immediate court relief is required.
Florida generally follows the rule that each party pays its own attorney’s fees unless a contract, statute, or other recognized legal basis authorizes recovery. The applicable agreements should be reviewed at the beginning of the dispute.
The timeline depends on the number of parties, the complexity of the facts, the amount of discovery, expert testimony, motion practice, the court’s calendar, and whether the case settles. Some disputes resolve within months, while complex cases may take considerably longer.
Depending on the claim, recoverable relief may include direct damages, consequential damages, lost profits, restitution, prejudgment interest, declaratory relief, specific performance, or injunctive relief. Contractual limitations and legal rules may restrict what can be recovered.
No. Some cases are decided by a judge, particularly when the parties waived a jury or seek equitable relief. Other cases may proceed to a jury trial. Arbitration provisions may require the dispute to be decided by an arbitrator instead of a court.
Preserve contracts, amendments, emails, text messages, accounting records, invoices, payment records, photographs, plans, electronic files, internal communications, and other materials relating to the dispute. Avoid deleting or modifying potentially relevant evidence.
Commercial disputes can escalate quickly and create significant financial and operational consequences. Early evaluation can help identify available claims, defenses, deadlines, evidence, and opportunities for resolution.
St. Johns Law Group represents businesses, property owners, developers, investors, landlords, tenants, contractors, professionals, and other commercial clients throughout St. Augustine, St. Johns County, Ponte Vedra, Nocatee, Jacksonville, Palm Coast, Flagler County, and Northeast Florida.
📞 Call 904.495.0400 or email info@sjlawgroup.com to schedule a consultation.
St. Johns Law Group uses cookies to operate our website, understand site usage, and measure advertising. You can accept all cookies or manage your choices.